Dr. Pickleball's Musings8 min read

Spinal Stenosis: Understanding Your Options Before Considering Surgery

A Norwegian study asks whether adding spinal fusion to decompression surgery actually improves outcomes — or just adds risk. Dr. Engasser explains the difference between back pain and leg pain, what the evidence shows, and why the biggest operation isn't always the best one.

By Mark C. Engasser, MD

What's on Tap Today?

Today we're talking about something that affects an awful lot of us as the birthdays accumulate: back pain, leg pain, and spinal stenosis.

And, more importantly, what happens when we decide to do something about it.

A recent Norwegian study raises an interesting question: When surgery is necessary to relieve pressure on the spinal nerves, does adding a spinal fusion actually improve the outcome?

Sometimes fusion is necessary. But sometimes a more limited operation may accomplish the same goal with less risk.

We'll explore the difference between back pain and leg pain, what the scientific evidence tells us, and why the biggest operation isn't necessarily the best one.

And because this is Doctor Pickleball, we've invited a construction crew to help explain things.

They may have brought a little more equipment than necessary.

Back Pain and Leg Pain: Two Very Different Problems

As an orthopedic surgeon, I've always appreciated the extraordinary advances in surgical technology. Better imaging, smaller incisions, improved instrumentation, and increasingly sophisticated techniques have transformed what we can accomplish.

But there's an old surgical principle worth remembering:

Just because we can do something doesn't necessarily mean we should.

This is particularly true when it comes to back surgery.

And for those of us who play pickleball, back pain is practically an occupational hazard.

Between bending for low balls, twisting for shots we probably should have let go, and occasionally moving like we're 35 when our birth certificates suggest otherwise, our backs take quite a beating.

Unfortunately, our spines aren't automobiles, although some of us have accumulated enough replacement parts to qualify as vintage restoration projects.

Back Pain Isn't Always the Same as Leg Pain

One of the most important distinctions in spine surgery is whether we're treating back pain or leg pain.

Back pain can arise from discs, facet joints, muscles, ligaments, and other degenerative changes.

Many of these changes appear on MRIs in people who have no pain whatsoever.

An abnormal MRI doesn't necessarily identify the source of the problem.

Leg pain caused by spinal stenosis or a herniated lumbar disc is often a different story.

Both conditions can compress or irritate nerves traveling from the lower back into the legs, but they do so in somewhat different ways.

Spinal stenosis occurs when narrowing of the spinal canal or nerve passageways places pressure on the nerves.

Patients may experience leg pain, numbness, weakness, or difficulty walking, particularly when standing upright.

Interestingly, many patients feel better leaning forward.

That's why someone who can barely walk across a parking lot may comfortably push a shopping cart around Costco for an hour.

Of course, the free samples may provide additional motivation.

A herniated lumbar disc, on the other hand, occurs when disc material protrudes or escapes and irritates or compresses a nearby nerve root.

This often produces sciatica — pain that travels from the buttock down the leg, sometimes accompanied by numbness, tingling, or weakness.

Unlike typical spinal stenosis, symptoms from a herniated disc may be aggravated by sitting, bending, coughing, or sneezing.

Fortunately, many herniated discs improve without surgery.

However, when disabling leg pain persists despite appropriate nonsurgical treatment, or significant neurological deficits develop, a carefully selected procedure such as a microdiscectomy can provide substantial relief.

The important distinction is that surgery for clearly identified nerve compression causing leg pain is often more predictable than surgery for nonspecific chronic back pain.

Whether we're treating spinal stenosis or a herniated disc, the surgical objective is essentially the same:

Relieve the pressure on the affected nerve while preserving as much normal spinal anatomy and stability as possible.

Not necessarily rebuild the entire spine.

After all, if the door is sticking, sometimes you just need to adjust the hinges — not replace the whole house.

Enter the Construction Crew

Traditionally, spinal stenosis surgery involves removing enough bone and ligament to relieve pressure on the nerves.

This is called decompression.

In some patients, surgeons also recommend spinal fusion, using screws, rods, and bone grafts to stabilize the spine.

Fusion can be appropriate and sometimes necessary.

However, adding fusion also makes the operation more extensive, potentially increasing operative time, blood loss, hospitalization, complications, and expense.

Sometimes you have to wonder whether the spine needs a small repair or a complete remodeling project.

What Did the Norwegian Researchers Find?

A November 2026 report in Annals of Internal Medicine, highlighted by MedPage Today, examined 2,252 Norwegian patients undergoing surgery for spinal stenosis associated with degenerative spondylolisthesis.

Degenerative spondylolisthesis occurs when one vertebra slips forward relative to another.

The researchers compared patients undergoing decompression alone with those receiving decompression plus fusion.

The findings were interesting:

  • Adding fusion did not produce a statistically significant improvement in disability at one year.
  • Fusion required approximately 85 additional minutes of surgery.
  • Hospital stays averaged nearly two days longer.
  • The overall risk of complications was approximately doubled.

An earlier Norwegian randomized trial, NORDSTEN-DS, also found that decompression alone was noninferior to decompression with fusion at five years in selected patients.

These studies don't mean fusion should never be performed.

They suggest that adding fusion routinely may not improve outcomes for many patients.

And that's important information when deciding how much surgery is really necessary.

When Every Problem Starts Looking Like a Nail

There's an old saying that when your only tool is a hammer, every problem starts looking like a nail.

Medicine has its own version of that problem.

When you're a surgeon, it's tempting to see a surgical solution. When you're a specialist, it's natural to view problems through the lens of your particular expertise.

And when you've spent years mastering a sophisticated procedure, it's understandable that you might believe it's the best answer.

But sometimes the patient doesn't need someone to demonstrate everything a surgeon knows how to do.

They need someone to ask whether there's a nail in the first place.

That's particularly relevant to spine surgery.

With today's sophisticated imaging, minimally invasive techniques, computer navigation, robotic assistance, and remarkable array of implants, surgeons have more options than ever before.

And that's generally a wonderful thing.

But just because we have an impressive collection of tools doesn't mean every patient needs the entire toolbox.

The question shouldn't be, "What treatment am I best at providing?" It should be, "What treatment is best for this particular patient?"

Sometimes that's a complex reconstruction.

Sometimes it's a limited decompression.

And sometimes the best treatment is no operation at all.

Are We Creating the Instability We're Trying to Prevent?

One reason surgeons recommend fusion is concern about spinal instability.

That's a legitimate consideration.

Are we treating instability that already exists, or could an overly extensive decompression create instability that might otherwise have been avoided?

The spine has important stabilizing structures, including the facet joints, ligaments, and supporting musculature.

A carefully performed limited decompression can often relieve nerve compression while preserving these structures.

Even bilateral decompression or decompression at multiple levels does not automatically require fusion.

The important considerations include existing instability, spinal alignment, the amount of facet joint removal, and how much structural support must be sacrificed to decompress the nerves adequately.

Some patients clearly need fusion.

But the decision should be based on the patient's specific anatomy and clinical circumstances rather than simply assuming that more extensive surgery produces better results.

We should be careful not to create instability through unnecessarily extensive surgery and then use that instability to justify an even bigger operation.

What About Surgery for Back Pain Alone?

This is another area where patients should be especially thoughtful.

Several randomized studies comparing lumbar fusion with intensive rehabilitation for chronic low back pain have shown little or no clinically meaningful advantage for fusion in broadly selected patients.

That doesn't mean spinal fusion never helps back pain.

It means that identifying the right patient, the right diagnosis, and the right operation is critically important.

Operating for well-defined nerve compression is different from operating simply because an MRI shows degenerative changes.

After all, if we operated on every abnormal MRI in people over 65, we'd probably have to convert half the pickleball courts into surgical recovery centers.

And the parking situation is already bad enough.

A Little Surgical Humility

I've known many surgeons who are exceptionally skilled, dedicated, and convinced that their preferred operation is the best approach.

And sometimes they're right.

But the real test of a treatment isn't how impressive the operation looks, how sophisticated the instrumentation is, or how strongly its proponents believe in it.

It's whether patients actually do better.

Surgeons are understandably proud of their work.

After all, if you've spent years mastering an operation, it's difficult to hear that a simpler procedure may accomplish the same thing.

But that's why we have randomized clinical trials.

They help separate what we hope is true from what we can demonstrate is true.

The best operation isn't the one that demonstrates everything a surgeon knows how to do. It's the one that accomplishes what the patient actually needs.

And sometimes that means leaving the hardware in the hardware store.

Five Questions to Ask Before Back Surgery

Before agreeing to surgery, particularly spinal fusion, consider asking your surgeon:

  • Am I having surgery primarily for back pain or leg pain? Which symptoms are most likely to improve?
  • Can the nerve compression be relieved with decompression alone? Why or why not?
  • Is my spine actually unstable? What findings demonstrate instability?
  • Could the proposed decompression create instability? Can a more limited technique preserve the supporting structures?
  • What are the additional benefits and risks of fusion in my particular situation? Would a second opinion be helpful?

A good surgeon should welcome these questions.

What About Avoiding Surgery?

Not everyone with spinal stenosis needs surgery.

Many patients can manage their symptoms through physical therapy, appropriate exercise, activity modification, medication, and sometimes injections.

Progressive neurological weakness or significant functional deterioration may require surgical evaluation. New urinary retention, loss of bladder or bowel control, or saddle anesthesia requires emergency assessment.

The goal isn't to avoid surgery at all costs.

It's to select the right treatment at the right time.

A Word From Dr. Pickleball

After a career in orthopedic surgery, I've developed tremendous respect for the complexity of spinal problems and the surgeons who treat them.

Sometimes a major reconstruction is exactly what's needed. Other times, a relatively limited procedure may accomplish the same goal.

The important thing is to understand what we're trying to fix.

If the problem is pressure on the nerves, perhaps taking that pressure away is enough. If the spine is unstable, additional stabilization may be necessary.

Good surgery isn't measured by how much we do. It's measured by how much we help.

And for those of us who love pickleball, the goal isn't a perfect-looking MRI or an impressive collection of surgical hardware.

It's being able to walk comfortably, enjoy life, and maybe reach one more drop shot that our partners were convinced we'd never get.

After all, when your house needs a little repair, you don't necessarily need to rebuild the foundation.

And the same may be true of your back.

See you on the court — or in the recliner!

Dr. Pickleball

Medical References

  • McAuley JH, et al. Norwegian registry analysis of decompression versus decompression with fusion for degenerative spondylolisthesis. Annals of Internal Medicine, 2026. Discussed in MedPage Today, November 2, 2026.
  • NORDSTEN-DS five-year follow-up. BMJ, 2024. https://www.bmj.com/content/386/bmj-2024-079771
  • Försth P, et al. A randomized, controlled trial of fusion surgery for lumbar spinal stenosis. New England Journal of Medicine, 2016. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa1513721
  • Fairbank J, et al. MRC Spine Stabilisation Trial. BMJ, 2005. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15911537/
  • WFNS Spine Committee. Fusion surgery for lumbar spinal stenosis: recommendations. World Neurosurgery: X, 2020. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7322802/

This article is for educational purposes and does not replace individualized medical advice.